-Only been an All-Star 2x
-Only 1 Gold Glove
-Only 1 Silver Slugger
Has he amassed some good offensive stats consistently and for a long time? It would appear so. He seems like he's been a good player over a considerably long period of time. And some of his numbers aren't that impressive:
-2,200+ hits (very nice, not HoF)
-#27 all-time on the strikeout list
Before this season, he had 12 straight seasons of 150+ hits - quite nice and consistent. Definitely NOT a Hall of Fame (Hall-of-Faker) candidate to me. Though a solid career for a long time - with power (some), speed, and OBP. And a decent AVG to boot... -StanO (11/16/10)
since when are all star appearances and gold gloves taken into account when casting hall of fame votes? It's almost exclusively offensive numbers. Not saying he is a HOF'er but your argument against him isn't the greatest.
ReplyDelete